Is Robin’s Return to Atlanta Really About Andi, or Is There More Than He’s Letting On?

Robin’s sudden return to Atlanta raises some interesting questions. Weren’t he supposed to be in London, establishing the firm’s UK division? When Andy asks why he’s back, he claims that Leland’s passing prompted his return to provide stability during this transition. Still, it seems like quite the coincidence, especially with Gary’s stabbing happening around the same time.

Despite how drawn out the “Who stabbed Gary?” storyline might feel, the writing keeps us on edge. Each character’s motivations are suspicious enough that you can’t let your guard down. It’s got a “Love Boat” vibe, where every guest appearance makes you wonder if they’re the culprit. Robin’s return defin

In the promo, Karen even questions Robin’s timing: “Isn’t it a bit convenient you show up just as Gary is stabbed?” Robin’s response to Andy’s inquiries about his knowledge of the situation feels equally unconvincing. He could have a legitimate inside contact, or perhaps he just wants Andy to think so. Either way, his vague answers don’t do much to inspire trust.

There are two possibilities here: either Robin stabbed Gary and knew questioning was inevitable, or he’s been keeping tabs on Andy since leaving Atlanta in Season 5. Remember, that’s when Madam made her appearance, marking Robin’s last known involvement. Has he been lurking, waiting for the right moment to step back in?

It’s also worth noting that, despite Andy’s interest, Robin wasn’t exactly treated well in their previous encounters. Sure, he pursued a woman engaged to someone else, but that dynamic has always been complicated. His return now feels like an attempt to rekindle something—though whether that’s wise is questionable.

Some fans point out that Robin, despite being ousted from the Atlanta division, still has overall control of the firm. He’s like the “farmer” of this law enterprise; he planted the seed that grew into a large firm with several branches. Being forced out of Atlanta didn’t mean he lost everything. Still, he did face financial pressure—remember the $3 million he had to raise? That challenge nearly broke him, but it doesn’t mean he’s broke now; he just couldn’t meet the time-sensitive demand.

High-net-worth individuals like Robin often don’t have cash on hand but hold significant assets and investments. For him, liquidating quickly was a hurdle, but it doesn’t mean he lacks wealth. He returned to Atlanta with some authority still intact—evident when he hands off Andy’s caseload to Hayden. His exact role might be unclear, but he has some control over company operations.

Then, there’s the matter of Jordan. Some wonder if Robin’s insistence that Andy avoid Jordan is legally motivated, to prevent her from jeopardizing the case. Or, is he being manipulative, possibly hoping to position himself as a better alternative to Gary? Whatever the reason, Robin’s actions are suspicious. It’s as if he’s still hiding something, and his “protective” stance toward Andy might be more self-serving than it appears.