‘Serial k.i.l.l.e.r’ John m.u.r.d.e.r.e.d Anthony and Nate, and now fans fear for Aaron
John has been suspicious since he first arrived
Fans have grown concerned about Aaron in Emmerdale as he has now become reliant on John. And they’re convinced more than ever that he has a d.e.a.d.l.y secret.
Ever since John Sugden appeared in the Emmerdale village, fans haven’t been able to warm to him. Every so often he does or says something that just makes him seem a bit off.
And last night, he was suspiciously good at covering up Anthony’s death – almost like he has had some practice.. That didn’t go unnoticed by fans. With many thinking he may have even had something to do with his d.e.a.t.h, so that Aaron would have a reason to need him.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/88ebb/88ebbd5ca67f05deed0114005d9c3d4db03bbbcc" alt="John and Aaron figure out how to deal with Anthony's body in Emmerdale"
Should we worry for Aaron in Emmerdale?
As soon as Aaron told John what happened, John seemed to switch straight into protective boyfriend mode. Which would have been cute – if we didn’t have our trust issues with him.
And fans all agree that there has to be more to come in Aaron and John’s story. Some think Anthony may not have been his first murder. Remember Nate? His exit still seems very suspicious.
One wrote: “What would John do to Aaron if he turned on him? He has the power now to destroy Aaron’s life. What would he do if Aaron broke up with him? And if Robert ever returns, Aaron has welded himself to John. What a conundrum it would be.”
Another added: “When people say John and Aaron were cute today but it’s so obvious that John is not what he seems. Open your eyes.”
A third theorised: “Always thought the way Nate just left was iffy. And there is something about John that had me thinking he maybe k.i.l.l.e.d him. And now tonight I deffo think he finished Anthony off. He knows it wasn’t Aaron.”
Is John a serial k.i.l.l.e.r?
It’s not just the Nate and Anthony theories that have fans convinced John is hiding something. It’s also the mysterious Aidan Moore.
While he told Aaron that Aidan was someone he loved but couldn’t save in Afghanistan, fans immediately thought he was lying. And while some thought he actually is Aidan Moore. A viewer gave a different suggestion.
They wrote: “So this Aidan Moore. I think John may have had something to do with his d.e.a.th. He was way too calm about covering up Anthony’s death. So how did he do it so easily?”
As Aaron in Emmerdale panics about now being a m.u.r.d.e.r.er, just how many twists are set to play out in their new storyline? And do you think fans are right to worry for Aaron’s safety?